Olivia’s Cafe is a casual and relaxing place that will bring you all the feelings of the Florida Keys. From brunch to dinner this casual dining restaurant is a favorite among Disney fans. 

Olivia’s Cafe is a hidden gem located in Disney’s Old Key West Resort. It’s one of the only restaurants on Disney property that serves brunch every day of the week! Disney describes it as “American eats with a Key West spin.”

If you are looking for a laid-back and beachy vibe, then Olivia’s Cafe is a must try. If you are stopping in for brunch, we suggest the famous Banana Bread Pudding or one of our favorites the Sombrero Beach Omelet.

When staying at Disney’s Old Key West Resort we always make sure to get a reservation and even if you are not staying here, I would say it’s still worth the visit to stop by and get brunch or dinner.

Olivia’s Cafe is a table service restaurant that serves American style food. You can get reservations for Brunch open daily from 7:30am – 2:00pm. If you want their amazing Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken then make a reservation for dinner from 5:00pm – 9:00pm.

Prices for both brunch and dinner range from $15-$37 and this restaurant is considered casual dining.

Brunch Menu:

If eating during brunch you will find the menu has specialty cocktails, appetizers, entrees, kids’ meals, and my favorite Joffrey’s coffee.

Please note: Menu Items are up to date as of the date of this post. The menu and specials and prices are subject to change.

The Specialty Cocktails include:

Magical Beacon Cocktail ($17.50)

Parrot Punch ($17.50)

Loaded Key West Bloody Mary ($14.50)

Olivia’s Eye Opener ($14.50)

Appetizers:

Shrimp Fritters ($13.00)

Oatmeal Brûlée ($7.00)

Fresh Fruit ($5.50)

Homemade Soup of the Day ($10.00)

Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken ($25.00)

Banana Bread Pudding ($16.00)

Caesar Salad ($11.00)

Caesar Salad with Shrimp ($18.00)

Bacon Cheeseburger ($21.00)

Olivia’s Breakfast ($16.00)

Buttermilk Pancakes and Eggs ($16.00)

Spam-Cheddar Biscuits ($15.00)

Shrimp and Grits ($24.00)

Caesar Salad with Chicken ($17.00)

Seasonal Market Salad ($12.00)

Sombrero Beach Omelet – pictured below ($17.00)

Papa’s Hash ($15.00) This is a plant-based option.

Conch Flats Club Sandwich ($17.00)

Dinner Menu:

Dinner offers lots of savory options as well as a dessert menu that will bring the taste of the Florida Keys right to you.

Please note: Menu Items are up to date as of the date of this post. The menu and specials and prices are subject to change.

Appetizers:

Crab Cake ($15.00)

Shrimp Fritters ($13.00)

Caesar Salad ($11.00)
Caesar Salad with Shrimp ($18.00)

Seasonal Market Salad ($12.00)

Homemade Soup of the Day ($10.00)

Caesar Salad with Chicken ($17.00)

Entrées:

Slow-cooked Prime Rib ($37.00)

Bacon Cheeseburger ($21.00)

Captain Wahoo’s Catch of the Day (price will vary)

Desserts:

Tropical Chocolate Torte ($9.00)

Olivia’s Bananas Foster ($9.00)

Key Lime Tart ($9.00)

Kid’s Menu:

These kids’ menu items are for kids 9 years and younger.

Please note: Menu Items are up to date as of the date of this post. The menu and specials and prices are subject to change.

Grilled Chicken ($11.00)

Elbow Pasta ($11.00)

Buttermilk-fried Chicken Strips – pictured below ($11.00)

Fish ($13.00)

All meals come with two sides. You can pick from green beans, fruit cup (pictured below), brown rice, or yogurt parfait with strawberries.

Drinks:

Fountain Beverages

Juices, milk, and tea. This is one if the few restaurants on Disney property that serves sweet tea.

During dinner they offer a several different non-alcoholic mock-tails.

Assorted beers, wines, cocktails, hard ciders, and hard seltzer.

Olivia’s also offers lots of allergy-friendly options as well. For more information on this menu check out the complete dinner menu.

Olivia’s Cafe to Go:

If you don’t want to take the time to sit down or can’t get a reservation, then check out Olivia’s Cafe to Go. You can order on the app then pick it up and take it with you.

This is a perfect way to taste the amazing food Olivia’s has to offer and eat it in the comfort of your resort room or out on one of the tables along the water or by the pool!

How to order Olivia’s to Go on the Disney My Experience App:

Just open your app and search for Olivia’s Cafe to Go. Then click Order Food and pick your time for pick up.

Once you have a pickup time you can build your order.

You can get almost everything that is on the normal menu to go.

Olivia’s Cancellation Policy:

If you can’t make your reservation, make sure to call and cancel at least 2 hours prior to your reservation time. If you fail to do this, you can be changed a $10 fee per person.

This is a major and recent change to Disney’s Dining Cancellation Policy. Prior to this change you had to cancel your reservations 24 hours in advance in order to avoid the fee.

• Cancellation Advice: If you miss the 2-hour window, still try calling the Dining reservation number to talk to them. Disney may be able to still help you out with the cancellation and possibly avoid the fee depending on the reasoning.

Walk-Up Reservations:

If you can’t make a reservation, you may be able to get on the list for a walk-up reservation. I would suggest to first check the app or give them a call.

If you are close to the restaurant, the app usually will tell the walk-up wait time, or if they are even taking walk-ups, are this time.

Olivia’s Cafe Final Review:

In closing, we love Olivia’s Cafe. It has become a regular reservation we try to make, even if not staying at Old Key West Resort. The food is great, and the atmosphere is really relaxed. The kids love it here as well.

Disney Dad Rating:

Our ratings are solely our opinion based on a scale of 1 to 10. 

Atmosphere – 8.5

Food – 8.0

Dining Area – 7.0

Service – 9

Overall Rating – 8.125

We hope you are enjoying sharing our Disney adventures and tips with you. We want you to have the best trip ever! Be sure to check out our other social media channels for more fun videos and posts FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM, YOUTUBE, TWITTER.

 Also our Facebook Group Disney World Insider Info and Tips is a great place to meet and chat with other Disney World fans like us!